Disable Preloader

CaseLaw

Nwanji V. Coastal services (2004) CLR 6(a) (SC)

Judgement delivered on June 22nd 2004

Brief

  • Special damages
  • Photocopy of document
  • Testimony and evidence of matters not pleaded
  • Claim for professional fees

Facts

The facts of this case are simple. The Plaintiff who is engaged in the business of shipping, warehousing, clearing and forwarding of goods entered into a contract with the Defendant, a transporter of goods. The contract was for the Defendant to transport some iron rods and bags of cement from the Warri Port to be delivered to the Fougerolle (Nig) Limited at Ajaokuta. It was alleged that those goods were not delivered, whereupon, the Plaintiff claimed for:

  • 1.
    Cost of goods.............. N74,254.60 (sic)
  • 2.
    Loss of commission from contract with Fougerolle (Nig) Ltd. N140,000.00
  • 3.
    Expenses incurred in making inquiries N10,000.00
  • 4.
    Cost of defending action by Fougerolle (Nig) Ltd. N20,000.00
  • 5.
    General damages N90,000.00
  • 6.
    Total N334,54.00

The Defendant contended that it delivered the goods and counterclaimed for N7,165.50 as special damages which he alleged the Plaintiff deducted from his entitlement and N88,924.44 as general damages which, however, did not add up to the N100,000.00 stated as the total counterclaim.

On 27 January, 1995, Narebor, J. sitting at the High Court, Warri, in an inordinately long judgment, having regard to the simple nature of the case, found for the Plaintiff and awarded damages as follows:

Issues

  • i.
    Whether Exhibit 'A’ the photocopy of the agreement between the parties...
    Read More